Alloy vs Winona

Official HRT page is unusually clear about consultation cost, messaging, and home delivery.

Adds a trusted women-focused hormone brand to a category that can otherwise skew too male-TRT heavy.

Fast treatment-plan turnaround is differentiated from clinic-first hormone providers.

This is not a full-spectrum longevity clinic with diagnostics, IV therapy, or peptide breadth.

Official site clearly positions Winona around hrt and broader longevity support.

Telehealth availability makes it easier to compare remote-care convenience against clinic-led alternatives.

Published service framing is strong enough to support provider, comparison, and location pages.

Membership structure can make the first visible price look cleaner than the full long-term cost.

Alloy: This is not a full-spectrum longevity clinic with diagnostics, IV therapy, or peptide breadth.

Winona: Membership structure can make the first visible price look cleaner than the full long-term cost.

Alloy has the cleaner current edge if you care most about transparency and a broader decision trail.

Winona may still fit better if its geography, clinic structure, or narrower service mix is closer to what you want.

Both providers share HRT and Menopause Care and 1 more — compare pricing models for those specific services before deciding.

Alloy: Labs, medication fulfillment, shipping, or follow-up consults may sit outside the headline price.

Winona: Labs, medication fulfillment, consults, or shipping may sit outside the headline price.

Alloy: Alloy's terms say subscriptions auto-renew unless canceled at least seven days before the end of the current subscription period by contacting support.

Winona: Cancellation or pause terms were not clearly listed on the reviewed official pages and should be checked directly.

Alloy: Alloy publishes multiple menopause-treatment starting prices directly on the product pages.

Winona: Users who want a menopause-only HRT comparison point with a straightforward digital funnel.

Alloy: Official Alloy pages show a one-time $49 doctor consultation fee and menopause hormone products starting at $39.99, with several estradiol formats listed at higher monthly prices.

Winona: Winona shows a visible starting price of $120 per month, but deeper pricing detail is not fully public on the reviewed pages.

Alloy: No mandatory membership fee is clearly highlighted in the normalized source data.

Winona: A recurring membership or subscription appears to be part of the offer, but the exact public fee still needs manual review.

Alloy: Alloy says users are assigned a menopause-trained doctor and can get a plan in as little as 12 hours, with unlimited messaging while the prescription is active.

Winona: A mandatory consult step was not clearly listed on the reviewed homepage.

Alloy: Alloy's terms say the service is not insurance. Product pages highlight FSA/HSA on some hormone options.

Winona: Insurance, HSA, or FSA handling was not fully verified from the reviewed official pages.

Alloy: Labs, medication fulfillment, shipping, or follow-up consults may sit outside the headline price.

Winona: Labs, medication fulfillment, consults, or shipping may sit outside the headline price.